How Old St. Mary’s Survived to Begin Again

Historic Places · From the Fall 2007 archive

How Old St. Mary’s Survived to Begin Again

The church’s story includes closures, a fallen steeple, changing congregations, and a last-minute rescue.

Historic Saint Mary’s church with its original steeple
Saint Mary’s before the steeple toppled in 1937, as reproduced in the Fall 2007 newsletter.

Old St. Mary’s did not pass smoothly from nineteenth-century church to restored landmark. Its survival depended on several new beginnings.

John Bolton donated the lot in 1882. Archbishop Joseph Alemany dedicated the church on August 13, 1883. It later closed in 1933, and its steeple fell in 1937.

A building searching for a future

The church reopened in 1946. The Catholic parish eventually outgrew the building, and the last Mass there was held on December 23, 1983. Other congregations used it afterward.

In 2001, a new owner sought permission to demolish the aging church to make room for business expansion. City staff alerted the Historical Society, which began negotiating to save it.

The rescue became a restoration

In 2005, Electrical Maintenance Consultants offered the church to the Society on the condition that it be moved promptly. On September 17, the building was relocated to the Heritage Park site near Front Street and Rocklin Road.

Restoration reached a major milestone in September 2007, and the building took the name Old Saint Mary’s Chapel. Gary Day’s account, published that fall, connects the restored landmark with the long and sometimes uncertain history that preceded it.

Source: Adapted from Gary Day’s “Saint Mary’s Through the Years”, Quarry Quarterly, Fall 2007, page 1, 4. This article is adapted from the Society’s newsletter archive; project status and personal details reflect that issue.

There’s more to discover

Keep reading.

From the same newsletter

More Historic Places

Back to all stories