140 Years of Old St. Mary’s: A Birthday Built on Preservation

Historic Places · From the Summer 2023 archive

140 Years of Old St. Mary’s: A Birthday Built on Preservation

A June 2023 celebration honored an 1883 chapel—and the community effort that saved it, moved it, and returned it to public life.

Volunteers beside birthday cakes at Old St. Mary’s 140th anniversary celebration
Peggy Russi and Nancy Lohse at the anniversary celebration. Photograph by Ronna Davis, from Quarry Quarterly, Summer 2023.

On June 30, 2023, Old St. Mary’s Chapel celebrated its 140th year with cake, photographs, tours, and stories. The celebration was held ahead of its August anniversary in hopes of avoiding the heat. Nancy Lohse’s report noted that the day reached 105 degrees anyway.

The building dated to 1883. By 2023, its survival was also a story of much more recent work: a community effort to prevent its loss and bring it to Heritage Park on Front Street.

Saving a building takes many people

Lohse recalled Gene Johnson’s approach to the Keller family about donating the chapel, Holly Clark’s help, and the support of schoolchildren who raised money for the effort. Councilman Peter Hill helped arrange the City’s purchase of the building to provide funds for the project.

Preparing the chapel for its move required steel reinforcement rods across its interior. It was one of many practical challenges in turning a preservation idea into a building that could be used again.

Celebrating the result

At the anniversary event, Linda Wampler’s slideshow traced changes to the chapel. Volunteers answered questions, the firehouse opened for tours, and the Fix-It Team brought out the Jubilee Train and historic fire equipment.

The report counted about 600 couples married in the chapel since 2007—a measure of how the saved building had become part of new family histories as well as an older one.

Lohse deliberately avoided trying to name every person who had contributed to the restoration. Too many had helped to fit into a short account. The birthday celebration honored that collective effort: a historic building still standing because residents had found a use for it and worked together to keep it.

Source: Adapted from Nancy Lohse’s anniversary report, Quarry Quarterly, Summer 2023, page 3. This article is adapted from the Society’s newsletter archive; project status and personal details reflect that issue.

There’s more to discover

Keep reading.

From the same newsletter

More Historic Places

Back to all stories